top of page

Have Your Say!

Writer: Kirrie Jenkins
Kirrie Jenkins
Jun 30
2 min read

The Mooir Vannin offshore windfarm proposal is one of the headline topics facing the Isle of Man right now and it will almost certainly still be one of the biggest issues during the general election.


Whatever side people sit on, support it, oppose it or are somewhere in the middle, it deserves proper scrutiny.


I registered as a stakeholder in the MIMA process back at the beginning of the public Inquiry and I’ve been involved in it from the start. I haven’t built my views from Facebook comments or headlines. I’ve attended every session, sat through the hearings, read the documents and followed the evidence as it has developed.


That is why I’ve been surprised, and if I’m honest disappointed, at how few politicians and election candidates I’ve seen engaging directly with the process.


This is a project that could affect the Island economically, environmentally and financially for decades, yet very few people who are asking for the public’s vote seem to have been sitting in the room.


You can support the project or oppose it. That’s not the issue. But if you’re making it part of your campaign, people should expect you to understand the detail first.


After reading through the MIMA submissions, one thing is very clear: the conversation is more complicated than “the Island gets nothing” or “it only creates 30 jobs”.


Treasury and Government departments have set out their view of where the benefits come from. A lot of the focus is on taxation of future profits, lease income from the seabed and wider economic benefits.


But there is also an important point which hasn’t had enough attention.


A lot of those projected financial benefits are still based on assumptions and proposed changes which don’t yet exist in law. Treasury’s own documents say that changes to taxation arrangements would require political approval.


So, when people throw around large headline figures, it is worth asking a simple question: what is already secured and what still depends on future decisions?


What has also been interesting for me personally is talking with campaigners involved in the offshore campaign. Having set up the campaign groups concerned with the Onshore wind turbine proposals Cair Vie Resistance, and the residents support group Earystane & Scard Windfarm Community Action Group, I’ve noticed something familiar.


The arguments change, but the frustrations don’t.


People want to feel they’ve been listened to.

People want proper engagement.

People want transparency.


There is another round of public engagement coming up and I genuinely hope we see more politicians and election candidates there this time. If we’re asking residents to engage with one of the biggest decisions facing the Island, then people asking for their vote should be engaging too.


You can follow the latest from the MIMA public inquiry here https://mima.gov.im/mooir-vannin/document-library/examination/deadline-4-responses/


Catch up on all the previous sessions and look at the latest round of responses.


There are further public sessions planned for the week 13th July – 17th July.


I’d recommend - Turn up - Read the evidence - Join the conversation.



 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
It’s the eve of polling day

The last few months have flown by and I have been reflecting on just how much this campaign has taught me. I’ve covered a huge amount of the constituency, spoken with so many of you on the doorstep an

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page