Mooir Vannin’s “Alternative Layout”: What the Developer’s Own Evidence Tells Us

One of the most interesting documents submitted during the latest Mooir Vannin examination is the “Without Prejudice Indicative Alternative Layout, which has appeared ahead of next weeks round of hearings.
This is effectively the developer’s Plan B.
The company makes it clear that it still wants approval for its original 1.4 GW proposal. However, recognising the strength of concerns raised during the examination, it has produced a smaller alternative that it says could be approved if the original scheme is considered unacceptable.
That alone is significant- an acknowledgement that concerns are justified
The revised layout reduces the number of turbines from up to 87 to 72 and cuts the footprint of the wind farm by almost half.
Why?
Because the developer accepts that moving turbines further offshore and reducing their spread will lessen the visual impact on the Isle of Man. It also accepts there will be improvements for commercial fishing and navigation.
In other words, the company is acknowledging that the issues raised by residents, fishermen, ferry operators and others are real enough to justify redesigning the project.
Yet, even with these changes, the developer admits that significant visual effects would remain.
The document repeats the claim that the original project could generate around £2.4 billion for the Isle of Man over its lifetime, compared with around £1.8 billion for the smaller scheme.
But when you read the detail, the revenue is not expected to arrive evenly over the life of the project.
The developer’s own financial profile shows:
relatively low government revenues in the early years while construction costs are recovered;
much higher revenues during the middle years when the project is at peak profitability; and
a significant decline after the Contracts for Difference (CfD) support period ends.
That means this is not a guaranteed annual income stream. It is a forecast based on assumptions about electricity prices, profitability, tax policy and the project’s commercial performance.
The document also makes another important point.
Some of the additional benefits offered to the Isle of Man—such as support for an Island electricity link or discounted electricity—are linked to the project remaining commercially viable under a 15% effective corporation tax assumption.
(I.e. Pillar Two of the OECD’s Global Anti-Base Erosion rules which aims to ensure that large multi national groups pay a minimum effective tax rate of 15% on profits in each jurisdiction where they operate.)
That illustrates how dependent the financial case is on future commercial conditions.
Like any long-term infrastructure project, forecasts over several decades inevitably involve uncertainty.
A compromise—not a solution?
The alternative layout is clearly an improvement in several respects.
According to the developer, it:
reduces visual impact;
avoids important scallop fishing grounds;
improves navigation; and
remains technically and commercially viable.
However, it also generates less electricity and lower forecast revenues.
The question for decision-makers therefore becomes:
Does the revised scheme reduce the impacts enough to justify approval, or does it simply make a large project slightly less harmful while leaving many of the fundamental concerns unresolved?
That is the issue the Examination Panel—and ultimately the Council of Ministers—will need to consider.
Whatever your view of the project, one thing is clear the developer’s own evidence contains much more nuance than the headline figures suggest.
Large revenue forecasts need to be understood in the context of how and when that money might actually arise. Environmental improvements need to be weighed against the fact that significant impacts would still remain.
For a project that could shape the Isle of Man’s landscape, economy and territorial waters for decades, it’s essential that decisions are based not on headlines, but on careful scrutiny of the evidence.
It’s well worth attending the inquiry to see the examination process for yourself. Look beyond the headlines and study the detail.


Comments